‘I Do Not Agree with the Phoenix’: The Lopez Who Rejected His Family's Oldest Story

Four months after ABS-CBN went dark, Federico "Piki" Lopez said what he had been thinking for years.

It was November 23, 2020. The country was still under pandemic lockdown. The Management Association of the Philippines had moved its annual awards to a livestream. No stage, no room, just a screen. Faces in small rectangles. Applause you could not hear. The occasion was prestigious enough: Piki, chairman and CEO of First Philippine Holdings, had just been named the 44th Management Man of the Year, exactly 20 years after his father Oscar received the same honor.

Midway through his acceptance speech, he arrived at the Lopez family's most sacred story: "If you can include our family's recent ABS-CBN challenges…you can see why we're drawn to the romantic narrative of the mythical Phoenix, which is also the title of our two-volume, 200-year history of seven generations of Lopezes. I have always been moved and inspired by the colorful history of my family and the achievements of my predecessors. It definitely has and always will have a place in my heart."

Then came the turn: "However, the notion of heroically rebuilding again and again from the ashes of a scorched bird is far from my idea of a narrative that should guide our destiny. I don't believe future generations of Lopezes should romanticize and be trapped by it."

And then Shakespeare, to a virtual room of the country's top executives: "I always remind myself that ‘The fault, dear Brutus, may not always be in our stars, but in ourselves’.”

The Shakespeare line was not decorative. In Julius Caesar, Cassius says it to Brutus to end his friend's habit of blaming the stars, fate, the gods—anything but themselves—for what has gone wrong. It is a line about refusing victimhood. Piki Lopez, receiving an award four months after a democratic legislature shut down his family's network, was using it to ask: was the phoenix story itself part of the problem?

Six years later, his cousins ousted him.

ALSO READ

Explainer: Who Really Owns Lopez Inc.—and Why the 29% Cousin Is in Charge

How the Lopez Family Lost Meralco

To understand what Piki was rejecting, start with a book.

Phoenix: The Saga of the Lopez Family, 1800–1999 was commissioned by the Eugenio Lopez Foundation and published in Manila in 2000, the year after Piki's uncle Eugenio “Geny” Lopez Jr. died. Its author was Raul Rodrigo. Its foreword was written by Oscar M. Lopez, Piki's father, dated February 7, 2000.

Oscar explained the title himself: “Like the phoenix, the Lopez family rose from the ashes after each defeat; it demonstrated this ability from its earliest generations.” He wrote it as a gift to the next generation, a “continuing lifeline from the past” that would “give the younger generation of Lopezes a sense of their history, which will be vital to business and family success in the new age.”

The book earns the metaphor. After former dictator Ferdinand Marcos Sr. seized the family's empire in 1972—Meralco extracted from patriarch Eñing; ABS-CBN shuttered overnight; First Holdings bled to near-nothing—the Lopez brothers came back after EDSA and rebuilt all of it from rubble. Oscar walked into First Holdings in April 1986 to find a dark building, P1 billion in debt, P3 million in cash, and 20 employees. “Oscar, why would you want to have anything to do with this big headache?” the outgoing company president asked him. Oscar replied: “Yes, well, sometimes I wonder myself why.”

Geny rebuilt ABS-CBN from a network with no equipment, no money, and last-place ratings into the dominant force in Philippine broadcasting by 1988, eventually capturing 45 percent of all advertising spending in the country. Manolo took Meralco from 21 percent systems losses and years of sequestration disputes fought through the DBP, the PCGG, the Sandiganbayan, and the Supreme Court to a company Asiamoney called the country's best-managed in 1996. Geny relaunched the Manila Chronicle on Independence Day 1986, pooling P1 million each from 19 business friends, and, together with business partner John Gokongwei Jr, helped rebuild PCIBank into the country's most profitable bank by 1990, later cited by Euromoney as the best bank in the Philippines for several consecutive years.

Four companies lost. Four rebuilt. The phoenix had worked. That was the point. That was also the problem.

Volume 2 of the book is divided into “Years in the Wilderness” and “Resurrection.” Chapter 16: “Up From the Ashes.” Epilogue: “Past, Present, Future.” The phoenix is not applied to the Lopez story after the fact. It is the skeleton the story is built on: destruction, exile, return. For the generation that actually lived through the dispossession and the rebuild, the metaphor was earned and real.

Oscar wrote that foreword for Piki's generation. Piki had watched the whole arc from the inside—he was barely 11 when Marcos Sr. began extracting the family's empire, and 27 when he left Harvard's MBA program in 1988 to come home and help his father rebuild a near-bankrupt First Holdings from the ground up. He knew the ashes were real because he had helped clear them.

In the MAP speech, he acknowledged the hold the story still had on him: it “definitely has and always will have a place in my heart.” Twenty years after that foreword was written, before a virtual room of the country's top executives, he said he did not agree with the phoenix.

Six years after that, he said it again.

April 2026. Piki walks into a townhall meeting with First Gen employees. Someone jokes that his blue shirt should have been red. He laughs, and the laughter settles into something more serious.

Piki has been ousted as president of Lopez Inc., the family holding company that sits above everything else: First Gen, FPH, ABS-CBN. Eugenio “Gabby” Lopez III, Geny's eldest son and Piki's cousin, controls 71 percent of Lopez Inc. with his faction. They voted Piki out. Piki got a court order blocking enforcement of the ouster. The fight is not over.

At the townhall, Piki does not dwell on the ouster's details. He tells his people there is no need to take sides, that shareholder conflicts have a way of working themselves out. Then he arrives at the argument that has been building for six years, now spoken with nothing left to lose: “Many of the things that we're doing are not the product of basically just one year or two years. This is the product of maybe 25, 30, even 40 years of doing the things we've been doing, building on it.”

It is Einstein, he says, who called compound interest “the most powerful force in the universe” because “those who know it, reap it; those who don't know it, pay.” And Charlie Munger, Warren Buffett's late partner, with the governing rule: “Just don't interrupt it, because the moment you keep interrupting it, then it falls apart, and then you have to start again from scratch.”

Having laid that down, the rejection of the phoenix follows naturally: “That's also one reason why I told the family, I do not agree with the Phoenix analogy. Because the Phoenix says, you burn down, you rise again, you burn down, you rise again. That stops compound interest, the most powerful force in the universe. I don't want that for our companies. I want us to keep going and going, and building and building.”

Compound interest is returns generating more returns. Each year's gain becoming the base from which the next year's gain grows, not in a straight line but exponentially. Slowly at first, then suddenly enormous. Not because of any dramatic event but because nothing stopped the accumulation. Think of a tree planted and never cut down: the first years are almost nothing, then real shade, then fruit, then enough to feed a neighborhood, not from any dramatic intervention, but simply because it was left alone to build on what it had already grown. Munger's rule, again: never interrupt it unnecessarily.

In the MAP speech, Piki said that after 26 years in business, the real lesson was something no classroom could teach. FPH's recurring net income grew at a compounded annual rate of 29 percent in the decade he led the company—from P1.18 billion in 2010 to P11.9 billion in 2019—not because of one brilliant decision, but because the accumulation was never interrupted.

The most recent expression of that philosophy is what First Gen, the gas and geothermal arm of FPH, is building right now. In early 2026, Piki led First Gen into a P62-billion deal to acquire a 33-percent stake in the pumped storage hydropower projects of Enrique Razon's Prime Infrastructure—the 600-megawatt Wawa project in Rizal and the 1,400-megawatt Ahunan facility in Laguna. Together, the two represent 2,000 megawatts of energy storage capacity. These are not projects that pay off next quarter. They are slated for completion by 2030 at the earliest, multi-year infrastructure bets requiring sustained capital, sustained expertise, and sustained patience. When finished, they transform First Gen's portfolio, adding large-scale hydro to the geothermal and gas base, moving the company closer to the no-coal, fully renewable vision Piki had declared publicly in 2016 and staked his reputation on in the MAP speech four years later.

Razon himself had written a specific provision into the deal requiring that Piki's group remain in charge of First Gen for it to proceed. An investor betting billions over multiple years does not write that kind of clause for a company he expects to reset from ash. The phoenix, by design, resets the clock. Every “rise again” is a new seed, and every burn erases decades. That is Piki's argument. Not that the family's history of resilience is not real or admirable, but that enshrining the cycle as destiny makes each reset feel inevitable, even noble, when it may in fact be avoidable.

The cousins are not simply invoking romance. They are making their own compounding argument, and it deserves to be heard on its own terms.

ABS-CBN's franchise expired in May 2020. In Congress, 70 representatives voted against renewal in July, a decision widely linked to former President Duterte's anger at the network. Close to 6,000 employees lost their jobs. The Gabby majority's position is that ABS-CBN's value—six decades of audience loyalty, cultural resonance, and trust built under Geny's founding mission of “In the Service of the Filipino”—is itself a compounded asset, and that withdrawing capital mid-stream destroys something that cannot be quickly rebuilt. ABS-CBN had survived Marcos. It had come back from the 1986 shutdown stronger and more dominant than before. The phoenix had worked. Why would it not work again?

The cousins have publicly alleged that Piki wanted ABS-CBN shut down entirely, and that his refusal to inject capital into the network was the reason they moved against him. People close to Piki dispute this account. A rebuttal statement was being prepared at the time of writing but had not yet been released. What is not in dispute is that Piki opposed the capital injection. ABS-CBN's official statement after the ouster leaned directly on Geny's founding words: “Our reason for being is and always will be to be in the Service of the Filipino.”

Both sides believe in not interrupting what is being built. They disagree on what that is—financial momentum or institutional mission, a renewable energy portfolio compounding across decades or a broadcast network carrying 60 years of audience trust. That is not a simple family feud. That is a genuine philosophical argument about what a 200-year family business is ultimately for.

Oscar closed his foreword in the book with this: “The saga of the Lopez family is an unending one, and future historians may write a fresh new volume that will be just as colorful and inspiring.”

In the MAP speech, Piki offered a different ending. Not a phoenix burning and rising, but a butterfly. It was not a casual metaphor for a man who had spent thousands of hours underwater with a camera, face to face with hammerhead and tiger sharks and a startled octopus that eventually extended a tentacle to touch his outstretched hand. He understood transformation from the inside.

He told the story of the caterpillar. Every caterpillar, he explained, harbors dormant imaginal cells, each carrying the potential to become something entirely different. As they begin to morph, the caterpillar's own immune system attacks them as outsiders. But as the imaginal cells multiply past a tipping point, the body stops fighting them and begins nourishing them instead. “The anguished and labored metamorphosis of a butterfly that can take to the sky in flight only begins the moment it's willing to give up being a caterpillar.”

The phoenix dies and rises as the same bird, over and over. The butterfly transforms once, irreversibly, into something it was not before. Then he quoted Leonard Cohen: “Ring the bells that still can ring. Forget your perfect offering. There is a crack in everything. That's how the light gets in.”

In the town hall, ousted and unbowed, he closed with compound interest: “We're not going to stop this compounding force from building us to what we should be.”

Oscar commissioned the book and wrote the foreword that explained its title. The

cousins are defending it. And Piki Lopez has now said, at least twice, that he

does not agree with the phoenix. The Lopez war will resolve in courtrooms and

shareholder agreements, but the question underneath it will outlast every legal

filing: when a family's founding myth becomes more powerful than its judgment,

who inside that family has the standing to say so?

He said it when it was safe. He said it again when it was not.

The 71-percent majority said: not you.