Is Now You See Me: Now You Don’t the Next Fast and Furious?

This long-awaited sequel to the magical heist movie is expanding its roster.
IMAGE PHOTO: IMDB / Now You See Me: Now You Don't

The third chapter in this saga of magicians who do good deeds in the form of heists brings back the original Four Horsemen — Danny Atlas (Jesse Eisenberg), Merrit McKinney (Woody Harrelson), Jack Wilder (Dave Franco), and Henley Reeves (Isla Fisher), who wasn’t in the second film — for more do-goodery and wealth redistribution. This time around, we meet a new generation of prestidigitators, Charlie (Justice Smith), Bosco Leroy (Dominic Sessa), and June (Ariana Greenblatt), who’ve since filled the void left behind by the Horsemen and use their magic tricks to bridge wealth inequality in their own little ways. In one trick, a bunch of predatory crypto bros get their comeuppance, seeing their digital assets distributed in real time to the people they’ve scammed, and it’s the sort of feel-good fiction that we could use in these strange times. Now You See Me: Now You Don’t really should’ve been the title for the second film, inexplicably and unimaginatively titled Now You See Me 2, but it is what it is.

ADVERTISEMENT - CONTINUE READING BELOW

ALSO READ:

The 26 Greatest Heist Movies Ever Made

A Very Serious Literary Analysis of the Fast and the Furious Films

There’s no shortage of callbacks and references to the first two films, making Now You See Me: Now You Don’t a real delight for fans. The three young upstarts are invited to participate in a grand scheme through mysterious tarot cards, similar to the first film. There are twists and surprises like the first two, and things aren’t always what they seem, although there’s nothing as clever as Dylan Shrike’s (Mark Ruffalo) reveal as the real mastermind or as satisfying as Thaddeus’ (Morgan Freeman) revelation as the Grandmaster of the Eye. In fact, Now You See Me: Now You Don’t is too busy pandering to nostalgia that it’s almost formulaic. One person isn’t who you think they are, and the film’s grand trick is another illusion similar to the safe in the first film and the plane in the second. Sure, as the audience, you aren’t aware of it while it’s happening, but the reveal is something of a letdown because it’s just the same trick with different props.

CONTINUE READING BELOW
watch now

Morgan Freeman and Woody Harrelson in 'Now You See Me: Now You Don't' (2025)

Morgan Freeman and Woody Harrelson
IMDB / Now You See Me: Now You Don't

Now You See Me: Now You Don’t is entertaining but suffers from a lack of ambition. Sure, the team’s mark is the scion of a Nazi whose wealth comes from blood diamonds and who uses her enterprise to launder money for the world’s worst criminals, but it never actually feels that way. The most dangerous thing about Rosamund Pike’s Veronika Vanderberg is her Afrikaans accent, which sounds Australian but evil, and the best thing about her might be that she’s reminiscent of Pike’s first movie role as Miranda Frost in Die Another Day. Vanderberg simply doesn’t exude the menace of a leader of a worldwide crime syndicate, and she seems to employ pitifully few henchmen. In one scene, she threatens to make one of her board members swallow a diamond that would rip his insides to shreds, but if you’ve seen Kill Bill’s O Ren Ishii (Lucy Liu) behead an uncooperative associate in the board room, Vanderberg’s threats just don’t land the same. Granted, the film is strictly PG fare, but the film’s big bad seems like she’s outclassed almost every step of the way.

ADVERTISEMENT - CONTINUE READING BELOW

The franchise is actually driven by grand ideas, and it’s kind of a shame that the sequel doesn’t have the courage or vision to follow through on them. The Eye is supposedly a secret cabal of magicians who’ve worked in secret throughout history, which is a terrific concept, but Now You See Me: Now You Don’t never ventures out of its own self-drawn lines and retreads all the same story beats explored in the first two films. In fact, it feels less like a sequel than a soft reboot, passing the torch to a new generation of magicians in anticipation of future films. Just like the Fast and Furious franchise, the Now You See Me trilogy is just adding more people, growing its magical family, and finding ways to perform the same tricks in new ways. But even Vin Diesel’s vehicular saga grew in scope and ambition with each film, evolving from an urban street racing action flick all the way to saving the world from armageddon.

Rosamund Pike in 'Now You See Me: Now You Don't' (2025)

Rosamund Pike
IMDB / Now You See Me: Now You Don't

This isn’t to say that the film doesn’t entertain. It certainly does that. But it entertains the same way a magician at a birthday party entertains — you’ve seen most of these tricks before, but you have a good time, anyway. The Now You See Me franchise actually has the potential to be better than popcorn fare. Unlike Fast and Furious or the Ocean’s series, Now You See Me actually tackles wealth disparity directly, and one might argue that it’s even the franchise’s core tenet. Now You See Me: Now You Don’t almost feels brave by making the main antagonist a Nazi descendant, which is more than apropos in these times, but it shies away from tackling bigger issues or even addressing actual Nazism, almost like it’s afraid to offend. But the best magic tricks in history challenged convention and shocked the senses. From David Blaine’s encasement in ice for 63 hours to Harry Houdini escaping the Chinese Water Torture Cell to David Copperfield making the Statue of Liberty disappear on live television, great magic rocks you to your core.

ADVERTISEMENT - CONTINUE READING BELOW

This is the biggest problem with Now You See Me: Now You Don’t. It’s not bad, but it could’ve been great. It’s afraid to be great in a time that calls for greatness. The film didn’t have the confidence to take the fight to the real villains; for a franchise that repeatedly depicts wealth redistribution, it’s baffling that it doesn’t scale up. The Dark Knight Rises saw Bane demolish the stock exchange, and Fight Club saw Tyler Durden throw the world economy into chaos by blowing up banking institutions, so why couldn’t the world’s greatest magicians trick more billionaires into signing away their wealth to balance the scales? This was always the franchise’s premise, and though they sort of do it here with Vanderberg, there’s an element of revenge (another reference to the first film) that dulls the impact of righting wrongs. Economic inequality has never been greater than at any other time in history, with the richest one percent in the United States growing wealth at 987 times more per household than the bottom 20 percent in the past 36 years. In the last year alone, the 10 richest people in the U.S. grew $698 billion richer while millions of Americans lose access to food assistance. If ever there was a time for genuine magic, it’s now.

The silver lining is that Now You See Me: Now You Don’t teases a sequel. The franchise could use the guiding hand of writer Ed Solomon, who wrote the first two films but whose absence is felt in this installment. After redistributing wealth to those ravaged by Hurricane Katrina in the first film to sticking it to crypto bros and slave drivers in the third, the franchise needs an encore that takes things to the next level. Now You See Me: Now You Don’t already goes a little bonkers with a magic house and Mission: Impossible-level legerdemain and illusion, so it might as well go the Fast and Furious route and go all out. Doing the same things again would be like having Penn and Teller perform at a kindergarten show and tell; it’s just wasted potential. This third chapter in the Now You See Me saga is serviceable, fun, and ok, even a little magical. But can the possible sequel live up to its true potential? That’s the magic trick we should all be waiting to see.

More from esquire

About The Author
Zach Yonzon
Zach really, really, really loves films.
View Other Articles From Kensei
Connect With Us